Re: [EPP-discuss] EPP funktioner / EPP features

From: Morten Møller Riis <mmr_at_gigahost.dk>
Date: Wed, 19 Feb 2014 15:43:22 +0100

Many of the features in the roadmap are pretty useless to us. It’ll never be a “correct” EPP implementation in my opinion, since the business model conflicts in so many ways.

So, fix the actual problems before doing half-hearted implementations or weird extensions (e.g. renew).

Mvh / Best regards
Morten Møller Riis
Gigahost ApS
mmr_at_gigahost.dk




On 19 Feb 2014, at 15:19, Peter Larsen <peter.larsen_at_larsendata.dk> wrote:

> Hi
>
> I don't think this is the email addresses you intended to post:
>
> tilregistrator_at_dk-hostmaster.dk toregistrator_at_dk-hostmaster.dk
>
>
>
> I have several comments to the paper, but I'm holding back for others to comment first here, but I need to comment this:
>
> "DK Hostmaster has not been provided with a viable business process description for what this feature should do and what would be expected from an implementation." - renew command
>
> Have we, or have we not, several times at the registrar meetings in København and århus the last few years been arguing for this?
>
> nov: 2010
>
> • Der var et ønske om at registratorerne kunne bruge renew commandoen i EPP, for på denne måde at kunne acceptere fornyelser på et vilkårligt tidspunkt på vegne af registranterne.
>
> maj 2012:
> • Definition af ”renew”. DK Hostmasters umiddelbare fortolkning af begrebet ”renew” havde været ”ændring af løbetid fremadrettet”. Registratorerne mente at ”Renew” omfattede muligheden for at forny et domænenavn. Registratorernes ønske vil indgå i listen over forslag til kommende ændringer i Step 2. DK Hostmaster kunne ikke garantere, at funktionaliteten ”renew” blev implementeret som ønsket, men der var tilsagn om at analysere ønsket.
>
> maj 2013:
>
> (København) Der blev spurgt hvornår EPP renew kommandoen og “realtid EPP” vil blive tilgængeligt. DK Hostmaster kan ikke svare på en specifik release dato for EPP renew da det afhænger resultaterne af procesprojektet som stadigvæk kører. Realtid EPP kan først blive lavet når e-mailformularen er afskaffet og at der er lavet en webformular til ansøgninger, plus en udfasningsperiode for e-mailformularen.
>
>
>
> Basicly, we have talked extensive about the renew command for 4 years, and now you tell me "DK Hostmaster has not been provided with a viable business process description for what this feature should do and what would be expected from an implementation" ??
>
> I guess it's a translation for "this is too much work for us, we are a sole registry, we rule" ... It makes me tired
>
> Shall we repeat it again?
>
>
> regards, Peter Larsen - ICANN Accredited registrar
>
> My info: http://larsen.tel
> Company info: http://larsendata.tel<Referat registratormøder maj 2013.pdf>
> <Referat Registratormøde nov 2010.pdf><Referat registratormøder maj 2012.pdf>
Received on Wed Feb 19 2014 - 15:43:22 CET

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.3.0 : Fri Feb 06 2015 - 11:39:21 CET